Image commercially licensed from: Unsplash

 

Purchasing commercial real estate can be a worthwhile investment opportunity. However, leasing also offers unique benefits for investors. This article provides a comparative analysis between acquiring and leasing. That way, you can determine which offers better returns.

Financial Implications 

The upfront costs differ between acquiring and leasing property. Acquisition requires large capital outlays for the buying price and closing costs. Investors must also secure financing, which usually demands a 20-25% down payment. 

Leasing requires little to no upfront costs. Tenants pay a security deposit, but landlords don’t contribute capital. This gives leasing an advantage when it comes to immediate cash flow requirements.

However, leasing properties long-term generates lower equity appreciation compared to ownership. While rental income accrues, values rise over time for purchased assets. Owners can realize large gains upon sale.

Both options also involve ongoing costs. For both leasing and acquisition, owners must pay property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and mortgage installments. Leasing requires the same costs, including taxes (not property tastes); however, it does not entail a mortgage.

Acquiring properties requires more initial capital but offers higher backend returns through appreciation. Leasing provides more consistent cash flow with less upfront investment.

Risk Mitigation Strategies

Investing in real estate poses many risks that must be managed. For example, you have market volatility and changes in supply and demand dynamics. Tenants also keep changing preferences. And regulatory changes will impact returns. Implementing prudent risk mitigation strategies is key for acquiring properties and leasing space.

For acquisitions, concentrate on markets with strong long-term fundamentals. It’s better than chasing short-term plays in this context. Factor in demographic and employment trends to identify geographies with growing demand. Avoid overpaying even in hot markets by sticking to rational valuations.

You should also diversify across different property types. Examples of those are office, retail, industrial, and multifamily. You also have short-term rental investing. It’s where owners put their personal property for rent for a period of time. The property can be a vacation house or a condo building.

Why Is It Important to Diversify?

Each sector has distinct demand drivers, so diversification smoothes out volatility. You should expand into different regions as well. This will balance markets with high growth versus more stable dynamics.

Manage financing risks by securing long-term fixed-rate debt. You should also maintain reasonable loan-to-value ratios below 75%. Stagger loan maturities and amortization schedules. Maintain reserves to manage unexpected costs and vacancies.

For leasing, tenant concentration poses major risks. We advise having a diverse mix of tenants across industries. Check financials and get strong guarantors. Divide space into smaller units to enable flexible re-leasing. 

Use longer lease terms of 10+ years to lock in rents through market cycles. But also balance with shorter leases that allow upward adjustments during rising markets. Avoid too much space turning over in a single year.

What Is Worth Consideration With Acquisition? 

With acquisitions, diversify both geographically and by property type. Monitor market conditions in each area and asset class. This will help optimize decisions on lease terms.

By taking these prudent measures, investors can build resilience against market swings. Assess risks through careful analysis rather than emotion. Then, adapt strategies to mitigate vulnerabilities.

Diversification across the major asset classes is key. Investment activity varies between property types. For example, the chart below shows the total U.S. commercial real estate investment volume. It has been broken down by sector.

Legal and Tax Considerations

Real estate transactions involve a myriad of legal and tax complexities. Savvy investors consult experts to structure deals and maximize benefits.

Acquisitions need legal, due diligence on the following:

• Titles
• Deeds
• Disclosures
• Zoning approvals
• Permitting

Environmental assessments help avoid liability issues. If assuming existing leases, analyze terms to understand obligations.

There are tax advantages to leverage. Mortgage interest and property taxes are deductible. Cost segregation strategies can speed up depreciation. Capital gains taxes apply on sales, but 1031 exchanges allow deferral. Estate planning is crucial.

Leasing also demands the following:

• Legal analysis of lease terms to balance landlord/tenant rights
• Ensure compliance with state and local security deposit and accounting rules.
• Check zoning permits
• Certificate of Occupancy status

Rental income is taxed at ordinary income rates. Meanwhile, these offsetting expenses are deductible:

• Utilities
• Maintenance
• Advertising and management fees
• Depreciation allowances on improvements

Legal and tax issues differ between residential and commercial real estate. Professionals equipped to handle complex business transactions are indispensable in this regard.

Asset Management 

For acquired assets, investors take an active role in property management. This involves the following responsibilities:

• Overseeing leasing
• Maintenance
• Tenant relations
• Marketing

Owners can outsource to a property management firm but still need to monitor it.

Leasing allows a more passive role. Landlords must approve tenants, but day-to-day operations are the tenant’s responsibility. This provides freedom from general hands-on management. What’s not included are the roof, walls, and structure. Anything related to the building must be consulted with the landlord. 

Preventative maintenance is essential for maximizing returns and minimizing expenses. Technological tools like HVAC monitors and security systems allow proactive maintenance. Capital improvements should be strategically planned.

Asset management ensures properties remain profitable. While leasing requires less involvement, investors must still monitor tenant compliance and satisfaction.

Market Trends and Future Projections

Understanding macro real estate trends allows informed acquisition and leasing decisions aligned with market conditions. Investing countercyclically can provide opportunity.

These are two examples of that statement:

• If the market favors tenants, long-term leases at fixed rates secure favorable ROI.
• If the market favors landlords, short-term leases have greater flexibility.

Factor in local supply and demand dynamics. Markets with major construction pipelines likely face increased competition. Areas with growing populations but constraints on new development offer better fundamentals.

No one can predict the future with certainty. However, examining historical cycles provides perspective, and demographic and economic trends offer clues. Adapt investment strategies accordingly.

Case Studies: Successes and Failures

Success: An investor purchased a Class B apartment community in 2010 when prices were low. He upgraded units and amenity spaces to reposition the asset. Upon selling in 2018, he got a 67% return from appreciation plus years of positive cash flow. 

Failure: An investor focused exclusively on leasing industrial space near a port. When ship traffic slowed due to economic factors, occupancy, and rental rates dropped. Lack of diversification left his entire portfolio vulnerable.

Success: A developer leased nine commercial condo units for 10+ years. This was just before market rents increased substantially. His locked-in returns remained stable throughout the upcycle.

Failure: When lease rates were peaking, an investor purchased several properties. He used 90% leverage. When the market softened, he couldn’t make mortgage payments. And he lost the buildings to foreclosure.

In both acquisition and leasing, diversification and financial analysis are keys to success. The final ingredient is risk assessment so you can avoid emotional decisions. That way, you can use prudent strategies.

FAQs: Common Real Estate Investment Questions 

What are the hidden costs to avoid?

For purchased property, hidden costs can include underestimating the renovation scope. Some also misjudge market demand and unexpected repairs. For leasing, hidden costs involve tenant defaults, legal disputes, and prolonged vacancies.

How can investors manage volatility? 

They can maintain reserves and diversify holdings over time. Additionally, they can secure favorable loan terms and optimize capital structure. Focus on geographic areas and asset classes with strong long-term fundamentals.

What legal risks should investors safeguard against?

Ensure compliance with all municipal codes and zoning. Vet all tenants and document inspections. Involve qualified legal counsel when signing leases or acquiring property.

Key Takeaways

• Weigh upfront costs vs. backend returns when comparing acquisition and leasing.
• Mitigate risk through diversification of locations, asset classes, lease terms, etc.
• Analyze market conditions but avoid overpaying even in frothy markets.
• Understand life cycle costs, not lease rates or buying prices.
• Involve legal and tax experts early in the investment process.

Strategically combining acquired properties with leased space can optimize returns while managing risk. Do thorough financial modeling and consider long-term market cycles. Time markets but always make decisions with discipline rather than emotion.