In the multifaceted world of American legal practice, few law firms are structured to both defend individuals facing criminal charges and pursue civil rights claims on behalf of those affected by institutional overreach. McKenzie Scott PC, based in San Diego, is among the few that operate effectively in both areas.
A Dual Approach to Community Advocacy
Founded by former federal public defenders Michele A. McKenzie and Timothy A. Scott, McKenzie Scott PC (MSPC) offers what it refers to as “community justice”- a model that integrates criminal defense and civil litigation under one roof. The team at MSPC is composed largely of former defenders from Federal Defenders of San Diego, Inc., bringing a depth of federal criminal trial experience to their work.
This dual framework allows McKenzie Scott attorneys to offer comprehensive legal representation. Their experience in public defense equips them to protect clients’ rights in criminal court, and, when appropriate, to seek remedies through civil litigation in cases where constitutional violations may have occurred.
“Our dual practice isn’t just about versatility; it’s about having a comprehensive understanding of how to help our clients navigate what’s often referred to as the ‘criminal legal system,’” says San Diego civil rights attorney Michele McKenzie.
“It’s not uncommon for a client to have their civil rights violated during an arrest, necessitating a good criminal defense as well as representation in an eventual tort claim,” San Diego criminal defense attorney Tim Scott says. “Defending individuals against criminal charges and holding authorities accountable for civil rights violations are often two sides of the same coin.”
Case Spotlight: The Lucky Phounsy Matter
One significant example of this integrated approach was the case involving Lucky Phounsy, a 32-year-old man who passed away in 2015 after a call to 911 during a mental health crisis. The incident involved a series of interactions with law enforcement that led to his hospitalization and eventual death.
Representing the family, Tim Scott served as lead trial counsel in a wrongful death and civil rights lawsuit. In March 2022, a jury awarded the family $85 million. At the time, it was one of the largest verdicts in a case involving an in-custody death.
“This case reflected the importance of accountability within the justice system,” Scott said following the verdict.
Broader Legal and Community Impact
The Phounsy verdict brought attention to several practices and procedures used during mental health interventions. It also highlighted issues surrounding the use of certain restraint techniques and underscored the need for clarity and transparency in law enforcement policies.
During the litigation process, disclosures related to training procedures were reviewed, and the case drew focus on the significance of institutional responsibility in high-stakes situations.
A Comprehensive Legal Resource
By working at the intersection of criminal defense and civil litigation, McKenzie Scott PC provides a rare breadth of legal service. The firm’s holistic model allows for continuous representation from initial defense to potential civil remedy, when warranted.
“Our goal is to ensure that justice is served, regardless of which side of the courtroom we’re on,” emphasizes McKenzie. “Everyone deserves a fair defense, and everyone deserves protection from abuses of power,” says Scott.
McKenzie Scott PC continues to serve the San Diego community and beyond with a commitment to advocacy and legal excellence.
For more information about McKenzie Scott PC and their work, please visit www.mckenziescott.com or connect via LinkedIn.
Disclaimer: The content of this article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers are encouraged to seek professional legal counsel for advice on their individual circumstances.